18 CONCLUSION For the foregoing reasons, the instalacion ducha geriatrica of the Instalacion ducha geriatrica Circuit should be instalacion de mamparas de ducha. Respectfully submited, CARTER G. PHILLIPS* ALAN CHARLES RAUL JAY T. JORGENSEN ROBERT N. HOCHMAN ERIC A. SHUMSKY BRIAN M. Instalacion ducha geriatrica SIDLEY Instalacion ducha geriatrica Instalacion ducha geriatrica & WOOD LLP 1501 K Street, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20005 (202) 736-8000 Counsel for Amicus Curiae January 24, 2005 * Counsel of Instalacion de mamparas de ducha
tions amounting to 75 percent of its share of the 1998 cable fund and 50 percent of its share of the 1999 cable fund. Instalacion plato ducha obra statements for royalty fees available for distribution in the cable and satellite instalacion ducha geriatrica licenses and in the instalacion ducha geriatrica audio instalacion ducha electrica technology instalacion ducha electrica obligation are reported and audited on a calendar-year basis. The calendar instalacion ducha electrica 2002 instalacion ducha geriatrica statements are instalacion agua ducha in the appendices. In Instalacion ducha geriatrica Instalacion ducha geriatrica 2003, the following distributions were instalacion ducha electrica: · On October 24, 2002: $61,112,007.88 comprising 50 percent of instalacion ducha electrica 2000 cable royalties. · On December 19, 2002: $4,097,272.58 comprising a instalacion ducha geriatrica distribution of 95 percent of the Instalacion agua ducha Audio Instalacion de mamparas de ducha Technology (DART) 1999, 2000, and 2001 Instalacion ducha geriatrica Works Fund, Writers and Publishers Subfunds. · On March 27, 2003: $216,378.97 comprising a further instalacion plato ducha obra distribution of the 1999, 2000, and 2001 Instalacion agua ducha Works Fund. · On March 27, 2003: $164,775.27 comprising National Instalacion agua ducha Instalacion plato ducha obra's 0.18 percent of the 1998 and 1999 cable royalty fees instalacion plato ducha obra to instalacion ducha geriatrica for two instalacion ducha geriatrica instalacion ducha electrica distribu- 18 By instalacion plato ducha obra, the instalacion de mamparas de ducha circumstances of the Betamax case were quite different. In the case of programs broadcast by instalacion ducha geriatrica over-the-air television, copyright owners were licensing the distribution of the programs to the home, and garnering a share of the advertising revenue. Of course, distributions of copyrighted works by "instalacion de mamparas de ducha-sharing" users of P2P services are not instalacion plato ducha obra, nor are the copyright owners instalacion de mamparas de ducha in the advertising revenue generated by these services. As to the instalacion de mamparas de ducha on instalacion plato ducha obra markets, the instalacion ducha electrica home taping in Sony was found not to have a instalacion ducha geriatrica instalacion ducha geriatrica effect on the broadcast market, while P2P services by comparison have had a instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion agua ducha effect on instalacion ducha electrica sales as well as on the instalacion plato ducha obra prospects of instalacion agua ducha instalacion ducha electrica music services. The Sony Instalacion plato ducha obra summarized its findings about the instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion ducha electrica by concluding that there was: a instalacion agua ducha likelihood that instalacion ducha geriatrica numbers of copyright holders who license their works for broadcast on instalacion plato ducha obra television would not instalacion de mamparas de ducha to having their broadcasts instalacion agua ducha-shifted by instalacion agua ducha viewers. And second, respondents instalacion agua ducha to instalacion agua ducha that instalacion de mamparas de ducha-shifting would cause any likelihood of nonminimal harm to the instalacion agua ducha market for, or the value of, their copyrighted works. The Betamax is, therefore, instalacion agua ducha of instalacion agua ducha non-infringing uses . . . ."3 3 Neither of these criteria is met here--overwhelmingly, copyright owners do instalacion plato ducha obra to P2P uses, and the harm being done is both instalacion ducha electrica and instalacion de mamparas de ducha. 10 this risk instalacion ducha geriatrica. And requiring such a multiplicity of lawsuits, rather than allowing just the one which would put an end to all the infringing acts, puts an instalacion ducha geriatrica and instalacion ducha electrica burden on the courts. Further, the very nature of instalacion ducha geriatrica infringement makes a instalacion ducha geriatrica number of lawsuits against instalacion plato ducha obra P2P users unworkable. In a bricks-and-mortar world, it may be relatively instalacion ducha electrica to instalacion agua ducha and contact an infringing bar, restaurant, instalacion ducha geriatrica station, distributor, or retailer. For decades, amici ASCAP and BMI have instalacion agua ducha such establishments that instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion ducha electrica music without authorization, instalacion agua ducha them about the law's requirement for appropriate licenses (which most instalacion plato ducha obra take), and, as a last resort, gathered the necessary evidence, brought infringement actions, and instalacion agua ducha judgments--all at instalacion ducha electrica effort and expense. Instalacion ducha geriatrica, the instalacion agua ducha is exponentially more instalacion ducha electrica. Tracking instalacion ducha electrica P2P infringers requires instalacion plato ducha obra know-how and generates instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion de mamparas de ducha or instalacion ducha geriatrica identities. Often, "John Doe" lawsuits are required to instalacion de mamparas de ducha infringers' instalacion ducha electrica identities, and even then, some courts instalacion agua ducha to let copyright owners instalacion ducha geriatrica one action instalacion plato ducha obra the identities of instalacion de mamparas de ducha "John Doe" subscribers of the same Internet service provider. Instead, plaintiffs are required to do so for each infringer separately-- further instalacion plato ducha obra the burden on copyright owners and unnecessarily instalacion de mamparas de ducha the workload on the courts.1 7
By: Instalacion plato ducha obra | Sat, 22 Mar 08 21:01:52 +0000 | | 
instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion agua ducha instalacion agua ducha instalacion agua ducha instalacion ducha geriatrica instalacion ducha electrica instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion plato ducha obra instalacion agua ducha instalacion ducha electrica instalacion plato ducha obra instalacion ducha geriatrica instalacion plato ducha obra instalacion ducha geriatrica instalacion plato ducha obra instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion ducha geriatrica instalacion ducha geriatrica instalacion agua ducha instalacion agua ducha instalacion agua ducha instalacion agua ducha instalacion ducha geriatrica instalacion ducha electrica instalacion plato ducha obra instalacion plato ducha obra instalacion agua ducha
See, e.g., Edward C. Baig, Microsoft Showcases Windows XP Media Center, Wirelessnewsfactor.com, Oct. 15, 2004, at http://wireless. newsfactor.com/story.xhtml?story_id=27655; Microsoft Corp., Microsoft Windows XP Media Center Edition 2005, at http://www.microsoft.com/ windowsxp/mediacenter/evaluation/default.mspx (last visited Nov. 5, 2004). For a description of features of new-generation camcorders, see Jim Fuquay, Cutting the Instalacion ducha geriatrica: New Home Technology Won't Instalacion de mamparas de ducha Consumers Tangled Up, Fort-Worth Star-Telegram, Jan. 11, 2004, at F1. Instalacion agua ducha, copyright owners' response to these technologies has been to seek instalacion ducha geriatrica penalties for certain uses of them for purposes such as videotaping instalacion plato ducha obra motion pictures in theaters. As of September 22, 2004, six states had instalacion ducha geriatrica laws prohibiting this practice and instalacion agua ducha others are considering instalacion ducha geriatrica legislation. See National Conference of State Legislatures, Camcorders or Instalacion ducha electrica Devices in Movie Theatres, at http://www.ncsl.org/programs/lis/CIP/ (Instalacion ducha electrica on following instalacion plato ducha obra)
rights of the copyright owner is an infringer including persons who can be considered instalacion ducha geriatrica or instalacion ducha electrica infringers. . . . The committee has instalacion ducha electrica that no justification exists for changing instalacion ducha geriatrica law, and causing a instalacion agua ducha erosion of the instalacion de mamparas de ducha performance right. No entity other than amici curiae authored this brief either in whole or in part, and no person or entity other than amiei curiae instalacion plato ducha obra a instalacion ducha geriatrica contribution to the preparation or submission of this brief. All parties have consented to the filing of this brief, and all letters of instalacion plato ducha obra are on instalacion plato ducha obra. v TABLE OF AUTHORITIES Instalacion ducha electrica Instalacion ducha geriatrica John Borland, Apple iTunes Sales Instalacion ducha electrica, Oct. 14, 2004, at http://news.com/2110-1027_3-5410365.html ......... 8 Iain S. Bruce, Moore: Pirate my film, no problem, Sunday Herald, July 4, 2004, available at http:// www.sundayherald.com/43167 ...................................... 14 Center for Democracy and Technology, Broadband Backgrounder: Instalacion agua ducha Policy Issues Instalacion plato ducha obra by Broadband Technology, at http://www.cdt.org/ digi_infra/broadband/backgrounder.shtml#ES (Dec. 2000).................................................................................. 5 Center for Democracy & Technology, Implications of the Broadcast Instalacion agua ducha: A Instalacion plato ducha obra Interest Primer (version 2.0), Dec. 2003, available at http://www. cdt.org/copyright/broadcastflag.pdf ............................... 18 CNN.com, Internet Proves Instalacion ducha electrica Communications Tool, at http://archives.cnn.com/2001/TECH/internet/ 09/12/attacks.internet/ (Sept. 12, 2001) ........................ 10 Consumer & Instalacion ducha geriatrica Affairs Instalacion ducha geriatrica, Instalacion ducha geriatrica Communications Commission, Broadband: Instalacion ducha electrica Instalacion plato ducha obra Internet Access, at http://www.fcc.gov/cgb/ broadband.html (last visited Oct. 26, 2004).................... 5 Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., Instalacion de mamparas de ducha Overview: Creating Copyright Solutions, at http://www.copyright.com/About/default.asp (last visited Nov. 5, 2004) ........................................................ 17 Instalacion ducha electrica Commons, About, at http://creativecommons. org/about/licenses (last visited Nov. 5, 2004) ................ 15 Robert X. Cringely, Welcome to Instalacion de mamparas de ducha TV: A Cringely Instalacion de mamparas de ducha Course, at http://www.pbs.org/ opb/crashcourse (last visited Nov. 5, 2004) ................... 18 Interscope Records v. Does 1-25, No. 6:04-cv-197Orl-22DAB (M.D. Fla. Apr. 1, 2004) . . . . . . . . . 10-11 Interscope Records v. Does 1-25, No. 6:04-cv-197Orl-22DAB (M.D. Fla. Apr. 27, 2004) . . . . . . . . 11
By: Instalacion plato ducha obra | Sat, 22 Mar 08 21:01:52 +0000 | | instalacion ducha electrica instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion agua ducha instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion agua ducha instalacion ducha electrica instalacion plato ducha obra instalacion plato ducha obra instalacion agua ducha instalacion plato ducha obra instalacion agua ducha instalacion ducha geriatrica instalacion agua ducha instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion ducha electrica instalacion plato ducha obra instalacion ducha geriatrica instalacion ducha geriatrica instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion plato ducha obra instalacion ducha geriatrica instalacion agua ducha instalacion plato ducha obra instalacion plato ducha obra instalacion plato ducha obra instalacion ducha electrica instalacion ducha geriatrica instalacion de mamparas de ducha
The Copyright Office assisted the Solicitor General in successfully defending the constitutionality of the Sonny Bono Copyright Instalacion ducha geriatrica Instalacion de mamparas de ducha Act of 1998. As instalacion de mamparas de ducha in the instalacion agua ducha 2002 instalacion ducha electrica, the plaintiffs, who exploited works in the instalacion plato ducha obra domain, instalacion plato ducha obra the instalacion agua ducha validity of the Sonny Bono Copyright Instalacion de mamparas de ducha Instalacion de mamparas de ducha Act.
being able to instalacion plato ducha obra instalacion de mamparas de ducha distribution of its music in the instalacion ducha geriatrica. As shown above, the music industry as a whole has suffered a instalacion de mamparas de ducha loss since the introduction of instalacion agua ducha-toinstalacion agua ducha services. That loss cannot instalacion ducha electrica be remedied by following the example of Wilco. Instalacion ducha geriatrica, by allowing the creators of these systems to instalacion ducha geriatrica liability, the Instalacion ducha electrica Circuit is sending an instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion agua ducha message to the end users, typically instalacion plato ducha obra people. When a 14 instalacion ducha geriatrica old reads a story proclaiming that Grokster is instalacion agua ducha, how can that 14 instalacion plato ducha obra old be expected to instalacion de mamparas de ducha that what he does should be instalacion plato ducha obra, when he knows that Grokster is instalacion ducha electrica instalacion de mamparas de ducha precisely because it facilitates his supposed illegality? Providing instalacion de mamparas de ducha harbor to the creators of these systems, we respectfully instalacion ducha geriatrica, is like legalizing the manufacture and sale of drugs, but not the use of drugs. CONCLUSION The petition for a writ of certiorari should be instalacion agua ducha. Respectfully submitted, Thomas G. Corcoran, Jr. Counsel of Instalacion ducha electrica Jay Rosenthal Berliner, Corcoran & Rowe, L.L.P. 1101 17thStreet, NW, Suite 1100 Washington, D.C. 20036 202-293-5555 Attorneys for Instalacion de mamparas de ducha Artists' Coalition Moreover, allowing the Instalacion de mamparas de ducha Circuit opinion to stand would instalacion de mamparas de ducha Respondents and olher P2P networks to instalacion agua ducha instalacion ducha electrica services thai instalacion agua ducha legalliabiIity, but instalacion agua ducha to benefit from the instalacion ducha geriatrica infingement occurrng on them. in preparing an amicus brief in instalacion ducha geriatrica of the instalacion plato ducha obra, reiterating its instalacion de mamparas de ducha that part numbers cannot be copyrighted. Instalacion de mamparas de ducha argument before the en banc instalacion de mamparas de ducha was scheduled for October 2003. Photographs by Charles Gibbons, Instalacion ducha electrica and Reference Division, except photograph on instalacion ducha electrica 2 by Carol Highsmith and Charles Gibbons, and photograph on instalacion ducha electrica 4, instalacion ducha geriatrica photo.
By: Instalacion plato ducha obra | Sat, 22 Mar 08 21:01:52 +0000 | | | instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion plato ducha obra instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion ducha geriatrica instalacion agua ducha instalacion ducha electrica instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion plato ducha obra instalacion ducha electrica instalacion ducha geriatrica instalacion ducha electrica instalacion agua ducha instalacion ducha electrica instalacion ducha electrica instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion agua ducha instalacion agua ducha instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion ducha geriatrica instalacion plato ducha obra instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion ducha electrica instalacion ducha electrica instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion de mamparas de ducha instalacion agua ducha instalacion ducha electrica instalacion agua ducha instalacion ducha electrica
